THE following reasons seem to have induced Paul to write this Second Epistle to the Corinthians: (1) That he might explain the reasons for his having deferred to pay them his promised visit, by taking Corinth as his way to Macedonia (@1Co 4:19 2Co 1:15,16; compare @1Co 16:5); and so that he might set forth to them his apostolic walk in general (@2Co 1:12,24 6:3-13 7:2). (2) That he might commend their obedience in reference to the directions in his First Epistle, and at the same time direct them now to forgive the offender, as having been punished sufficiently (@2Co 2:1-11 7:6-16). (3) That he might urge them to collect for the poor saints at Jerusalem (@2Co 8:1-9,15). (4) That he might maintain his apostolic authority and reprove gainsayers.

      The external testimonies for its genuineness are IRENÆUS [Against Heresies, 3,7,1]; ATHENAGORAS [Of the Resurrection of the Dead]; CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA [Miscellanies, 3, p. 94; 4, p. 101]; TERTULLIAN [On Modesty, 13].

      The TIME OF WRITING was after Pentecost, A.D. 57, when Paul left Ephesus for Troas. Having stayed in the latter place for some time preaching the Gospel with effect (@2Co 2:12), he went on to Macedonia, being eager to meet Titus there, having been disappointed in his not coming to Troas, as had been agreed on between them. Having heard from him the tidings he so much desired of the good effect produced on the Corinthians by his First Epistle, and after having tested the liberality of the Macedonian churches (@2Co 8:1), he wrote this Second Epistle, and then went on to Greece, where he abode for three months; and then, after travelling by land, reached Philippi on his return at Passover or Easter, A.D. 58 (@Ac 20:1-6). So that this Epistle must have been written about autumn, A.D. 57.

      Macedonia was THE PLACE from which it was written (@2Co 9:2, where the present tense, "I boast," or "am boasting," implies his presence then in Macedonia). In Asia (Lydian Asia) he had undergone some great peril of his life (@2Co 1:8,9), whether the reference be [PALEY] to the tumult at Ephesus (@Ac 19:23-41), or, as ALFORD thinks, to a dangerous illness in which he despaired of life. Thence he passed by Troas to Philippi, the first city which would meet him in entering Macedonia. The importance of the Philippian Church would induce him to stay there some time; as also his desire to collect contributions from the Macedonian churches for the poor saints at Jerusalem. His anxiety of mind is recorded (@2Co 7:5) as occurring when he came into Macedonia, and therefore must have been at Philippi, which was the first city of Macedonia in coming from Troas; and here, too, from @2Co 7:6, compared with @2Co 7:5, must have been the scene of his receiving the comforting tidings from Titus. "Macedonia" is used for Philippi in @2Co 11:9, as is proved by comparison with @Php 4:15,16. So it is probably used here (@2Co 7:5). ALFORD argues from @2Co 8:1, where he speaks of the "grace bestowed on the churches (plural) of Macedonia," that Paul must have visited other churches in Macedonia, besides Philippi, when he wrote, for example, Thessalonica, Berea, &c., and that Philippi, the first on his route, is less likely to have been the scene of his writing than the last on his route, whichever it was, perhaps Thessalonica. But Philippi, as being the chief town of the province, was probably the place to which all the collections of the churches were sent. Ancient tradition, too (as appears from the subscription to this Epistle), favors the view that Philippi was the place from which this Epistle was sent by the hands of Titus who received, besides, a charge to prosecute at Corinth the collection which he had begun at his first visit (@2Co 8:6).

      The STYLE is most varied, and passes rapidly from one phase of feeling to another; now joyous and consolatory, again severe and full of reproof; at one time gentle and affectionate, at another, sternly rebuking opponents and upholding his dignity as an apostle. This variety of style accords with the warm and earnest character of the apostle, which nowhere is manifested more beautifully than in this Epistle. His bodily frailty, and the chronic malady under which he suffered, and which is often alluded to (@2Co 4:7 5:1-4 12:7-9; compare Note, see on 2Co 1:8), must have been especially trying to one of his ardent temperament. But besides this, was the more pressing anxiety of the "care of all the churches." At Corinth, as elsewhere, Judaizing emissaries wished to bind legal fetters of letter and form (compare @2Co 3:3-18) on the freedom and catholicity of the Church. On the other hand, there were free thinkers who defended their immorality of practice by infidel theories (@1Co 15:12,32-36). These were the "fightings without," and "fears within" (@2Co 7:5,6) which agitated the apostle's mind until Titus brought him comforting tidings from Corinth. Even then, while the majority at Corinth had testified their repentance, and, as Paul had desired, excommunicated the incestuous person, and contributed for the poor Christians of Judea, there was still a minority who, more contemptuously than ever, resisted the apostle. These accused him of crafty and mercenary motives, as if he had personal gain in view in the collection being made; and this, notwithstanding his scrupulous care to be above the possibility of reasonable suspicion, by having others besides himself to take charge of the money. This insinuation was palpably inconsistent with their other charge, that he could be no true apostle, as he did not claim maintenance from the churches which he founded. Another accusation they brought of cowardly weakness; that he was always threatening severe measures without daring to execute them (@2Co 10:8-16 13:2); and that he was vacillating in his teaching and practice, circumcising Timothy, and yet withholding circumcision from Titus; a Jew among the Jews, and a Greek among the Greeks. That most of these opponents were of the Judaizing party in the Church, appears from @2Co 11:22. They seem to have been headed by an emissary from Judea ("he that cometh," @2Co 11:4), who had brought "letters of commendation" (@2Co 3:1) from members of the Church at Jerusalem, and who boasted of his purity of Hebrew descent, and his close connection with Christ Himself (@2Co 11:13,23). His partisans contrasted his high pretensions with the timid humility of Paul (@1Co 2:3); and his rhetoric with the apostle's plain and unadorned style (@2Co 11:6,10:10,13). It was this state of things at Corinth, reported by Titus, that caused Paul to send him back forthwith thither with this Second Epistle, which is addressed, not to Corinth only (@1Co 1:2), but to all the churches also in Achaia (@2Co 1:1), which had in some degree been affected by the same causes as affected the Corinthian Church. The widely different tone in different parts of the Epistle is due to the diversity which existed at Corinth between the penitent majority and the refractory minority. The former he addresses with the warmest affection; the latter with menace and warning. Two deputies, chosen by the churches to take charge of the contribution to be collected at Corinth, accompanied Titus (@2Co 8:18,19,22).

      @2Co 1:1-24. THE HEADING; PAUL'S CONSOLATIONS IN RECENT TRIALS IN ASIA; HIS SINCERITY TOWARDS THE CORINTHIANS; EXPLANATION OF HIS NOT HAVING VISITED THEM AS HE HAD PURPOSED.

      1. Timothy our brother--When writing to Timothy himself, he calls him "my son" (@1Ti 1:18). Writing of him, "brother," and "my beloved son" (@1Co 4:17). He had been sent before to Macedonia, and had met Paul at Philippi, when the apostle passed over from Troas to Macedonia (compare @2Co 2:12,13; see on 1Co 16:10,11).
      in all Achaia--comprising Hellas and the Peloponnese. The Gentiles themselves, and Annæus Gallio, the proconsul (@Ac 18:12-16), strongly testified their disapproval of the accusation brought by the Jews against Paul. Hence, the apostle was enabled to labor in the whole province of Achaia with such success as to establish several churches there (@1Th 1:8 2Th 1:4), where, writing from Corinth, he speaks of the "churches," namely, not only the Corinthian, but others also--Athens, Cenchrea, and, perhaps, Sicyon, Argos, &c. He addresses "the Church in Corinth," directly, and all "the saints" in the province, indirectly. In @Ga 1:2 all the "churches" are addressed directly in the same circular Epistle. Hence, here he does not say, all the churches, but "all the saints."

      3. This thanksgiving for his late deliverance forms a suitable introduction for conciliating their favorable reception of his reasons for not having fulfilled his promise of visiting them (@2Co 1:15-24).
      Father of mercies--that is, the SOURCE of all mercies (compare @Jas 1:17 Ro 12:1).
      comfort--which flows from His "mercies" experienced. Like a true man of faith, he mentions "mercies" and "comfort," before he proceeds to speak of afflictions (@2Co 1:4-6). The "tribulation" of believers is not inconsistent with God's mercy, and does not beget in them suspicion of it; nay, in the end they feel that He is "the God of ALL comfort," that is, who imparts the only true and perfect comfort in every instance (@Ps 146:3,5,8 Jas 5:11).

      4. us--idiomatic for me (@1Th 2:18).
      that we may . . . comfort them which are in any trouble--Translate, as the Greek is the same as before, "tribulation." The apostle lived, not to himself, but to the Church; so, whatever graces God conferred on him, he considered granted not for himself alone, but that he might have the greater ability to help others [CALVIN]. So participation in all the afflictions of man peculiarly qualified Jesus to be man's comforter in all his various afflictions (@Isa 50:4-6 Heb 4:15).

      5. sufferings--standing in contrast with "salvation" (@2Co 1:6); as "tribulation" (distress of mind), with comfort or "consolation."
      of Christ--Compare @Col 1:24. The sufferings endured, whether by Himself, or by His Church, with which He considers Himself identified (@Mt 25:40,45 Ac 9:4 1Jo 4:17-21). Christ calls His people's sufferings His own suffering: (1) because of the sympathy and mystical union between Him and us (@Ro 8:17 1Co 4:10); (2) They are borne for His sake; (3) They tend to His glory (@Eph 4:1 1Pe 4:14,16).
      abound in us--Greek, "abound unto us." The order of the Greek following words is more forcible than in English Version, "Even so through Christ aboundeth also our comfort." The sufferings (plural) are many; but the consolation (though singular) swallows up them all. Comfort preponderates in this Epistle above that in the first Epistle, as now by the effect of the latter most of the Corinthians had been much impressed.

      6. we . . . afflicted . . . for your consolation--exemplifying the communion of saints. Their hearts were, so to speak, mirrors reflecting the likenesses of each other (@Php 2:26,27) [BENGEL]. Alike the afflictions and the consolations of the apostle tend, as in him so in them, as having communion with him, to their consolation (@2Co 1:4 4:15). The Greek for "afflicted" is the same as before, and ought to be translated, "Whether we be in tribulation."
      which is effectual--literally, "worketh effectually."
      in the enduring, &c.--that is, in enabling you to endure "the same sufferings which we also suffer." Here follows, in the oldest manuscripts (not as English Version in the beginning of @2Co 1:7), the clause, "And our hope is steadfast on your behalf."

      7. so shall ye be--rather, "So are ye." He means, there is a community of consolation, as of suffering, between me and you.

      8, 9. Referring to the imminent risk of life which he ran in Ephesus (@Ac 19:23-41) when the whole multitude were wrought up to fury by Demetrius, on the plea of Paul and his associates having assailed the religion of Diana of Ephesus. The words (@2Co 1:9), "we had the sentence of death in ourselves," mean, that he looked upon himself as a man condemned to die [PALEY]. ALFORD thinks the danger at Ephesus was comparatively so slight that it cannot be supposed to be the subject of reference here, without exposing the apostle to a charge of cowardice, very unlike his fearless character; hence, he supposes Paul refers to some deadly sickness which he had suffered under (@2Co 1:9,10). But there is little doubt that, had Paul been found by the mob in the excitement, he would have been torn in pieces; and probably, besides what Luke in Acts records, there were other dangers of an equally distressing kind, such as, "lyings in wait of the Jews" (@Ac 20:19), his ceaseless foes. They, doubtless, had incited the multitude at Ephesus (@Ac 19:9), and were the chief of the "many adversaries" and "[wild] beasts," which he had to fight with there (@1Co 15:32 16:9). His weak state of health at the time combined with all this to make him regard himself as all but dead (@2Co 11:29 12:10). What makes my supposition probable is, that the very cause of his not having visited Corinth directly as he had intended, and for which he proceeds to apologize (@2Co 1:15-23), was, that there might be time to see whether the evils arising there not only from Greek, but from Jewish disturbers of the Church (@2Co 11:29), would be checked by his first Epistle; there not being fully so was what entailed on him the need of writing this second Epistle. His not specifying this here expressly is just what we might expect in the outset of this letter; towards the close, when he had won their favorable hearing by a kindly and firm tone, he gives a more distinct reference to Jewish agitators (@2Co 11:22).
      above strength--that is, ordinary, natural powers of endurance.
      despaired--as far as human help or hope from man was concerned. But in respect to help from God we were "not in despair" (@2Co 4:8).

      9. But--"Yea."
      in God which raiseth the dead--We had so given up all thoughts of life, that our only hope was fixed on the coming resurrection; so in @1Co 15:32 his hope of the resurrection was what buoyed him up in contending with foes, savage as wild beasts. Here he touches only on the doctrine of the resurrection, taking it for granted that its truth is admitted by the Corinthians, and urging its bearing on their practice.

      10. doth deliver--The oldest manuscripts read, "will deliver," namely, as regards immediately imminent dangers. "In whom we trust that He will also (so the Greek) yet deliver us," refers to the continuance of God's delivering help hereafter.

      11. helping together by prayer for us--rather, "helping together on our behalf by your supplication"; the words "for us" in the Greek following "helping together," not "prayer."
      that for the gift, &c.--literally, "That on the part of many persons the gift (literally, 'gift of grace'; the mercy) bestowed upon us by means of (that is, through the prayers of) many may be offered thanks for (may have thanks offered for it) on our behalf."

      12. For--reason why he may confidently look for their prayers for him.
      our rejoicing--Greek, "our glorying." Not that he glories in the testimony of his conscience, as something to boast of; nay, this testimony is itself the thing in which his glorying consists.
      in simplicity--Most of the oldest manuscripts read, "in holiness." English Version reading is perhaps a gloss from @Eph 6:5 [ALFORD]. Some of the oldest manuscripts and versions, however, support it.
      godly sincerity--literally, "sincerity of God"; that is, sincerity as in the presence of God (@1Co 5:8). We glory in this in spite of all our adversities. Sincerity in Greek implies the non-admixture of any foreign element. He had no sinister or selfish aims (as some insinuated) in failing to visit them as he had promised: such aims belonged to his adversaries, not to him (@2Co 2:17). "Fleshly wisdom" suggests tortuous and insincere courses; but the "grace of God," which influenced him by God's gifts (@Ro 12:3 15:15), suggests holy straightforwardness and sincere faithfulness to promises (@2Co 1:17-20), even as God is faithful to His promises. The prudence which subserves selfish interests, or employs unchristian means, or relies on human means more than on the Divine Spirit, is "fleshly wisdom."
      in the world--even in relation to the world at large, which is full of disingenuousness.
      more abundantly to you-ward--(@2Co 2:4). His greater love to them would lead him to manifest, especially to them, proofs of his sincerity, which his less close connection with the world did not admit of his exhibiting towards it.

      13. We write none other things (in this Epistle) than what ye read (in my former Epistle [BENGEL]; present, because the Epistle continued still to be read in the Church as an apostolic rule). CONYBEARE and HOWSON think Paul had been suspected of writing privately to some individuals in the Church in a different strain from that of his public letters; and translates, "I write nothing else to you but what ye read openly (the Greek meaning, 'ye read aloud,' namely, when Paul's Epistles were publicly read in the congregation, @1Th 5:27); yea, and what you acknowledge inwardly."
      or acknowledge--Greek, "or even acknowledge." The Greek for "read" and for "acknowledge" are words kindred in sound and root. I would translate, "None other things than what ye know by reading (by comparing my former Epistle with my present Epistle), or even know as a matter of fact (namely, the consistency of my acts with my words)."
      even to the end--of my life. Not excluding reference to the day of the Lord (end of @2Co 1:14 1Co 4:5).

      14. in part--In contrast to "even to the end": the testimony of his life was not yet completed [THEOPHYLACT and BENGEL]. Rather, "in part," that is, some of you, not all [GROTIUS, ALFORD]. So in @2Co 2:5 Ro 11:25. The majority at Corinth had shown a willing compliance with Paul's directions in the first Epistle: but some were still refractory. Hence arises the difference of tone in different parts of this Epistle. See Introduction.
      your rejoicing--your subject of glorying or boast. "Are" (not merely shall be) implies the present recognition of one another as a subject of mutual glorying: that glorying being about to be realized in its fulness "in the day (of the coming) of the Lord Jesus."

      15. in this confidence--of my character for sincerity being "acknowledged" by you (@2Co 1:12-14).
      was minded--I was intending.
      before--"to come unto you before" visiting Macedonia (where he now was). Compare Note, see on 1Co 16:5; also see on 1Co 4:18, which, combined with the words here, implies that the insinuation of some at Corinth, that he would not come at all, rested on the fact of his having thus disappointed them. His change of intention, and ultimate resolution of going through Macedonia first, took place before his sending Timothy from Ephesus into Macedonia, and therefore (@1Co 4:17) before his writing the first Epistle. Compare @Ac 19:21,22 (the order there is "Macedonia and Achaia," not Achaia, Macedonia); @Ac 20:1,2.
      that ye might have a second benefit--one in going to, the other in returning from, Macedonia. The "benefit" of his visits consisted in the grace and spiritual gifts which he was the means of imparting (@Ro 1:11,12).

      16. This intention of visiting them on the way to Macedonia, as well as after having passed through it, must have reached the ears of the Corinthians in some way or other--perhaps in the lost Epistle (@1Co 4:18 5:9). The sense comes out more clearly in the Greek order, "By you to pass into Macedonia, and from Macedonia to come again unto you."

      17. use lightness--Was I guilty of levity? namely, by promising more than I performed.
      or . . . according to the flesh, that with me there should be yea, yea . . . nay, nay?--The "or" expresses a different alternative: Did I act with levity, or (on the other hand) do I purpose what I purpose like worldly (fleshly) men, so that my "yea" must at all costs be yea, and my "nay" nay [BENGEL, WINER, CALVIN], (@Mt 14:7,9)? The repetition of the "yea" and "nay" hardly agrees with ALFORD'S view, "What I purpose do I purpose according to the changeable purposes of the fleshly (worldly) man, that there may be with me the yea yea, and the nay nay (that is, both affirmation and negation concerning the same thing)?" The repetition will thus stand for the single yea and nay, as in @Mt 5:37 Jas 5:12. But the latter passage implies that the double "yea" here is not equivalent to the single "yea": BENGEL'S view, therefore, seems preferable.

      18. He adds this lest they might think his DOCTRINE was changeable like his purposes (the change in which he admitted in @2Co 1:17, while denying that it was due to "lightness," and at the same time implying that not to have changed, where there was good reason, would have been to imitate the fleshly-minded who at all costs obstinately hold to their purpose).
      true--Greek, "faithful" (@1Co 1:9).
      our word--the doctrine we preach.
      was not--The oldest manuscripts read "is not."
      yea and nay--that is, inconsistent with itself.

      19. Proof of the unchangeableness of the doctrine from the unchangeableness of the subject of it, namely, Jesus Christ. He is called "the Son of God" to show the impossibility of change in One who is co-equal with God himself (compare @1Sa 15:29 Mal 3:6).
      by me . . . Silvanus and Timotheus--The Son of God, though preached by different preachers, was one and the same, unchangeable. Silvanus is contracted into Silas (@Ac 15:22; compare @1Pe 5:12).
      in him was yea--Greek, "is made yea in Him"; that is, our preaching of the Son of God is confirmed as true in Him (that is, through Him; through the miracles wherewith He has confirmed our preaching) [GROTIUS]; or rather, by the witness of the Spirit which He has given (@2Co 1:21,22) and of which miracles were only one, and that a subordinate manifestation.

      20. Rather, How many soever be the promises of God, in Him is the "yea" ("faithfulness in His word": contrasted with the "yea and nay," @2Co 1:19, that is, inconstancy as to one's word).
      and in him Amen--The oldest manuscripts read, "Wherefore through Him is the Amen"; that is, In Him is faithfulness ("yea") to His word, "wherefore through Him" is the immutable verification of it ("Amen"). As "yea" is His word, so "Amen" is His oath, which makes our assurance of the fulfilment doubly sure. Compare "two immutable things (namely, His word and His oath) in which it was impossible for God to lie" (@Heb 6:18 Re 3:14). The whole range of Old Testament and New Testament promises are secure in their fulfilment for us in Christ.
      unto the glory of God by us--Greek, "for glory unto God by us" (compare @2Co 4:15), that is, by our ministerial labors; by us His promises, and His unchangeable faithfulness to them, are proclaimed. CONYBEARE takes the "Amen" to be the Amen at the close of thanksgiving: but then "by us" would have to mean what it cannot mean here, "by us and you."

      21. stablisheth us . . . in Christ--that is, in the faith of Christ--in believing in Christ.
      anointed us--As "Christ" is the "Anointed" (which His name means), so "He hath anointed (Greek, "chrisas") us," ministers and believing people alike, with the Spirit (@2Co 1:22 1Jo 2:20,27). Hence we become "a sweet savor of Christ" (@2Co 2:15).

      22. sealed--A seal is a token assuring the possession of property to one; "sealed" here answers to "stablisheth us" (@2Co 1:21 1Co 9:2).
      the earnest of the Spirit--that is, the Spirit as the earnest (that is, money given by a purchaser as a pledge for the full payment of the sum promised). The Holy Spirit is given to the believer now as a first instalment to assure him his full inheritance as a son of God shall be his hereafter (@Eph 1:13,14). "Sealed with that Holy Spirit of promise which is the earnest of our inheritance until the redemption of the purchased possession" (@Ro 8:23). The Spirit is the pledge of the fulfilment of "all the promises" (@2Co 1:20).

      23. Moreover I--Greek, "But I (for my part)," in contrast to GOD who hath assured us of His promises being hereafter fulfilled certainly (@2Co 1:20-22).
      call God--the all-knowing One, who avenges wilful unfaithfulness to promises.
      for a record upon my soul--As a witness as to the secret purposes of my soul, and a witness against it, if I lie (@Mal 3:5).
      to spare you--in order not to come in a rebuking spirit, as I should have had to come to you, if I had come then.
      I came not as yet--Greek, "no longer"; that is, I gave up my purpose of then visiting Corinth. He wished to give them time for repentance, that he might not have to use severity towards them. Hence he sent Titus before him. Compare @2Co 10:10,11, which shows that his detractors represented him as threatening what he had not courage to perform (@1Co 4:18,19).

      24. Not for that--that is, Not that. "Faith" is here emphatic. He had "dominion" or a right to control them in matters of discipline, but in matters of "faith" he was only a "fellow helper of their joy" (namely, in believing, @Ro 15:13 Php 1:25). The Greek is, "Not that we lord it over your faith." This he adds to soften the magisterial tone of @2Co 1:23. His desire is to cause them not sorrow (@2Co 2:1,2), but "joy." The Greek for "helpers" implies a mutual leaning, one on the other, like the mutually supporting buttresses of a sacred building. "By faith (@Ro 11:20) ye stand"; therefore it is that I bestow such pains in "helping" your faith, which is the source of all true "joy" (@Ro 15:13). I want nothing more, not to lord it over your faith.

      @2Co 2:1-17. REASON WHY HE HAD NOT VISITED THEM ON HIS WAY TO MACEDONIA; THE INCESTUOUS PERSON OUGHT NOW TO BE FORGIVEN; HIS ANXIETY TO HEAR TIDINGS OF THEIR STATE FROM TITUS, AND HIS JOY WHEN AT LAST THE GOOD NEWS REACHES HIM.

      1. with myself--in contrast to "you" (@2Co 1:23). The same antithesis between Paul and them appears in @2Co 2:2.
      not come again . . . in heaviness--"sorrow"; implying that he had already paid them one visit in sorrow since his coming for the first time to Corinth. At that visit he had warned them "he would not spare if he should come again" (see on 2Co 13:2; compare @2Co 12:14 13:1). See Introduction to the first Epistle. The "in heaviness" implies mutual pain; they grieving him, and he them. Compare @2Co 2:2, "I make you sorry," and @2Co 2:5, "If any have caused grief (sorrow)." In this verse he accounts for having postponed his visit, following up @2Co 1:23.

      2. For--proof that he shrinks from causing them sorrow ("heaviness").
      if I--The "I" is emphatic. Some detractor may say that this (@2Co 2:1) is not my reason for not coming as I proposed; since I showed no scruple in causing "heaviness," or sorrow, in my Epistle (the first Epistle to the Corinthians). But I answer, If I be the one to cause you sorrow, it is not that I have any pleasure in doing so. Nay, my object was that he "who was made sorry by me" (namely, the Corinthians in general, @2Co 2:3; but with tacit reference to the incestuous person in particular) should repent, and so "make me glad," as has actually taken place; "for . . . who is he then that?" &c.

      3. I wrote this same unto you--namely, that I would not come to you then (@2Co 2:1), as, if I were to come then, it would have to be "in heaviness" (causing sorrow both to him and them, owing to their impenitent state). He refers to the first Epistle (compare @1Co 16:7; compare @1Co 4:19,21 5:2-7,13).
      sorrow from them of whom I ought to rejoice--that is, sorrow from their impenitence, when he ought, on the contrary, to have joy from their penitent obedience. The latter happy effect was produced by his first Epistle, whereas the former would have been the result, had he then visited them as he had originally proposed.
      having confidence . . . that my joy is the joy of you all--trusting that you, too, would feel that there was sufficient reason for the postponement, if it interfered with our mutual joy [ALFORD]. The communion of saints, he feels confident in them "ALL" (his charity overlooking, for the moment the small section of his detractors at Corinth, @1Co 13:7), will make his joy (@2Co 2:2) their joy.

      4. So far from my change of purpose being due to "lightness" (@2Co 1:17), I wrote my letter to you (@2Co 2:3) "out of much affliction (Greek, 'trouble') and anguish of heart, and with many tears."
      not that ye should be grieved--Translate, "be made sorry," to accord with the translation, @2Co 2:2. My ultimate and main object was, "not that ye might be made sorry," but that through sorrow you might be led to repentance, and so to joy, redounding both to you and me (@2Co 2:2,3). I made you sorry before going to you, that when I went it might not be necessary. He is easily made sorry, who is admonished by a friend himself weeping [BENGEL].
      that ye might know the love--of which it is a proof to rebuke sins openly and in season [ESTIUS], (@Ps 141:5 Pr 27:6). "Love" is the source from which sincere reproof springs; that the Corinthians might ultimately recognize this as his motive, was the apostle's aim.
      which I have more abundantly unto you--who have been particularly committed to me by God (@Ac 18:10 1Co 4:15 9:2).

      5. grief . . . grieved--Translate as before, "sorrow . . . made sorry." The "any" is a delicate way of referring to the incestuous person.
      not . . . me, but in part--He has grieved me only in part (compare @2Co 1:14 Ro 11:25), that is, I am not the sole party aggrieved; most of you, also, were aggrieved.
      that I may not overcharge--that I may not unduly lay the weight of the charge on you all, which I should do, if I made myself to be the sole party aggrieved. ALFORD punctuates, "He hath not made sorry me, but in part (that I press not too heavily; namely, on him) you all." Thus "you all" is in contrast to "me"; and "in part" is explained in the parenthetical clause.

      6. Sufficient--without increasing it, which would only drive him to despair (@2Co 2:7), whereas the object of the punishment was, "that (his) spirit might be saved" in the last day.
      to such a man--a milder designation of the offender than if he had been named [MEYER]. Rather, it expresses estrangement from such a one who had caused such grief to the Church, and scandal to religion (@Ac 22:22 1Co 5:5).
      this punishment--His being "delivered to Satan for the destruction of the flesh"; not only excommunication, but bodily disease (see on 1Co 5:4,5).
      inflicted of many--rather, "by the majority" (the more part of you). Not by an individual priest, as in the Church of Rome, nor by the bishops and clergy alone, but by the whole body of the Church.

      7. with overmuch sorrow--Greek, "with HIS overmuch sorrow."

      8. confirm your love toward him--by giving effect in act, and showing in deeds your love; namely, by restoring him to your fellowship and praying for his recovering from the sickness penally inflicted on him.

      9. For--Additional reason why they should restore the offender, namely, as a "proof" of their obedience "in all things"; now in love, as previously in punishing (@2Co 2:6), at the apostle's desire. Besides his other reasons for deferring his visit, he had the further view, though, perhaps, unperceived by them, of making an experiment of their fidelity. This accounts for his deferring to give, in his Epistle, the reason for his change of plan (resolved on before writing it). This full discovery of his motive comes naturally from him now, in the second Epistle, after he had seen the success of his measures, but would not have been a seasonable communication before. All this accords with reality, and is as remote as possible from imposture [PALEY, Horæ Paulinæ]. The interchange of feeling is marked (@2Co 2:4), "I wrote . . . that ye might know the love," &c.: here, "I did write, that I might know the proof of you."

      10. Another encouragement to their taking on themselves the responsibility of restoring the offender. They may be assured of Paul's apostolic sanction to their doing so.
      for if I forgave anything, to whom I forgave it--The oldest manuscripts read, "For even what I have forgiven, if I have forgiven anything."
      for your sakes forgave I it--He uses the past tense, as of a thing already determined on; as in @1Co 5:3, "I have judged already"; or, as speaking generally of forgiveness granted, or to be granted. It is for your sakes I have forgiven, and do forgive, that the Church (of which you are constituent members) may suffer no hurt by the loss of a soul, and that ye may learn leniency as well as faithfulness.
      in the person of Christ--representing Christ, and acting by His authority: answering to @1Co 5:4, "In the name of our Lord Jesus Christ . . . my spirit, with the power of our Lord Jesus Christ."

      11. Literally, "That we may have no advantage gained over us by Satan," namely, by letting one of our members be lost to us through despair, we ourselves furnishing Satan with the weapon, by our repulsive harshness to one now penitent. The loss of a single sinner is a common loss; therefore, in @2Co 2:10, he said, "for your sakes." Paul had "delivered" the offender "to Satan for the destruction of the flesh, that the Spirit might be saved" (@1Co 5:5). Satan sought to destroy the spirit also: to let him do so, would be to give him an advantage, and let him overreach us.
      not ignorant of his devices--"Ignorant" and "devices" are words akin in sound and root in Greek: we are not without knowledge of his knowing schemes.

      12. Paul expected to meet Titus at Troas, to receive the tidings as to the effect of his first Epistle on the Corinthian Church; but, disappointed in his expectation there, he passed on to Macedonia, where he met him at last (@2Co 7:5,6,7) The history (Acts) does not record his passing through Troas, in going from Ephesus to Macedonia; but it does in coming from that country (@Ac 20:6); also, that he had disciples there (@Ac 20:7), which accords with the Epistle (@2Co 2:12, "a door was opened unto me of the Lord"). An undesigned coincidence marking genuineness [PALEY, Horæ Paulinæ]. Doubtless Paul had fixed a time with Titus to meet him at Troas; and had desired him, if detained so as not to be able to be at Troas at that time, to proceed at once to Macedonia to Philippi, the next station on his own journey. Hence, though a wide door of Christian usefulness opened to him at Troas, his eagerness to hear from Titus the tidings from Corinth, led him not to stay longer there when the time fixed was past, but he hastened on to Macedonia to meet him there [BIRKS].
      to preach--literally, "for the Gospel." He had been at Troas before, but the vision of a man from Macedonia inviting him to come over, prevented his remaining there (@Ac 16:8-12). On his return to Asia, after the longer visit mentioned here, he stayed seven days (@Ac 20:6).
      and--that is, though Paul would, under ordinary circumstances, have gladly stayed in Troas.
      door . . . opened . . . of the Lord--Greek, "in the Lord," that is, in His work, and by His gracious Providence.

      13. no rest in my spirit--rather, "no rest for my spirit" (@Ge 8:9). As here his "spirit" had no rest; so in @2Co 7:5, his "flesh." His "spirit" under the Holy Spirit, hence, concluded that it was not necessary to avail himself of the "door" of usefulness at Troas any longer.
      taking . . . leave of them--the disciples at Troas.

      14. Now--Greek, "But." Though we left Troas disappointed in not meeting Titus there, and in having to leave so soon so wide a door, "thanks be unto God," we were triumphantly blessed in both the good news of you from Titus, and in the victories of the Gospel everywhere in our progress. The cause of triumph cannot be restricted (as ALFORD explains) to the former; for "always," and "in every place," show that the latter also is intended.
      causeth us to triumph--The Greek, is rather, as in @Col 2:15, "triumphs over us": "leadeth us in triumph." Paul regarded himself as a signal trophy of God's victorious power in Christ. His Almighty Conqueror was leading him about, through all the cities of the Greek and Roman world, as an illustrious example of His power at once to subdue and to save. The foe of Christ was now the servant of Christ. As to be led in triumph by man is the most miserable, so to be led in triumph by God is the most glorious, lot that can befall any [TRENCH]. Our only true triumphs are God's triumphs over us. His defeats of us are our only true victories [ALFORD]. The image is taken from the triumphal procession of a victorious general. The additional idea is perhaps included, which distinguishes God's triumph from that of a human general, that the captive is brought into willing obedience (@2Co 10:5) to Christ, and so joins in the triumph: God "leads him in triumph" as one not merely triumphed over, but also as one triumphing over God's foes with God (which last will apply to the apostle's triumphant missionary progress under the leading of God). So BENGEL: "Who shows us in triumph, not [merely] as conquered, but as the ministers of His victory. Not only the victory, but the open 'showing' of the victory is marked: for there follows, Who maketh manifest."
      savour--retaining the image of a triumph. As the approach of the triumphal procession was made known by the odor of incense scattered far and wide by the incense-bearers in the train, so God "makes manifest by us" (His now at once triumphed over and triumphing captives, compare @Lu 5:10, "Catch," literally, "Take captive so as to preserve alive") the sweet savor of the knowledge of Christ, the triumphant Conqueror (@Col 2:15), everywhere. As the triumph strikes the eyes, so the savor the nostrils; thus every sense feels the power of Christ's Gospel. This manifestation (a word often recurring in his Epistles to the Corinthians, compare @1Co 4:5) refutes the Corinthian suspicions of his dishonestly, by reserve, hiding anything from them (@2Co 2:17 2Co 4:2).

      15. The order is in Greek, "For (it is) of Christ (that) we are a sweet savor unto God"; thus, the "for" justifies his previous words (@2Co 2:14), "the savor of HIS (Christ's) knowledge." We not only scatter the savor; but "we are the sweet savor" itself (@So 1:3; compare @Joh 1:14,16 Eph 5:2 1Jo 2:27).
      in them that are saved--rather, "that are being saved . . . that are perishing" (see on 1Co 1:18). As the light, though it blinds in darkness the weak, is for all that still light; and honey, though it taste bitter to the sick, is in itself still sweet; so the Gospel is still of a sweet savor, though many perish through unbelief [CHRYSOSTOM, Homilies, 5.467], (@2Co 4:3,4,6). As some of the conquered foes led in triumph were put to death when the procession reached the capitol, and to them the smell of the incense was the "savor of death unto death," while to those saved alive, it was the "savor of life," so the Gospel was to the different classes respectively.
      and in them--in the case of them. "Those being saved" (@2Co 3:1-4:2): "Those that are perishing" (@2Co 4:3-5).

      16. savour of death unto death . . . of life unto life--an odor arising out of death (a mere announcement of a dead Christ, and a virtually lifeless Gospel, in which light unbelievers regard the Gospel message), ending (as the just and natural consequence) in death (to the unbeliever); (but to the believer) an odor arising out of life (that is, the announcement of a risen and living Saviour), ending in life (to the believer) (@Mt 21:44 Lu 2:34 Joh 9:39).
      who is sufficient for these things?--namely, for diffusing aright everywhere the savor of Christ, so diverse in its effects on believers and unbelievers. He here prepares the way for one purpose of his Epistle, namely, to vindicate his apostolic mission from its detractors at Corinth, who denied his sufficiency. The Greek order puts prominently foremost the momentous and difficult task assigned to him, "For these things, who is sufficient?" He answers his own question (@2Co 3:5,6), "Not that we are sufficient of ourselves, but our sufficiency is of God, who hath made us able (Greek, 'sufficient') ministers," &c.

      17. not as many--(@2Co 11:18 Php 2:21). Rather, "the many," namely, the false teachers of whom he treats (tenth through twelfth chapters, especially @2Co 11:13 1Th 2:3).
      which corrupt--Greek, "adulterating, as hucksters do wine for gain" (@2Co 4:2 Isa 1:22 2Pe 2:3, "Make merchandise of you").
      as of sincerity . . . as of God--as one speaking from (out of) sincerity, as from (that is, by the command of, and so in dependence on) God.
      in Christ's--as united to Him in living membership, and doing His work (compare @2Co 12:19). The whole Gospel must be delivered such as it is, without concession to men's corruptions, and without selfish aims, if it is to be blessed with success (@Ac 20:27).

      @2Co 3:1-18. THE SOLE COMMENDATION HE NEEDS TO PROVE GOD'S SANCTION OF HIS MINISTRY HE HAS IN HIS CORINTHIAN CONVERTS: HIS MINISTRY EXCELS THE MOSAIC, AS THE GOSPEL OF LIFE AND LIBERTY EXCELS THE LAW OF CONDEMNATION.

      1. Are we beginning again to recommend ourselves (@2Co 5:12) (as some of them might say he had done in his first Epistle; or, a reproof to "some" who had begun doing so)!
      commendation--recommendation. (Compare @2Co 10:18). The "some" refers to particular persons of the "many" (@2Co 2:17) teachers who opposed him, and who came to Corinth with letters of recommendation from other churches; and when leaving that city obtained similar letters from the Corinthians to other churches. The thirteenth canon of the Council of Chalcedon (A.D. 451) ordained that "clergymen coming to a city where they were unknown, should not be allowed to officiate without letters commendatory from their own bishop." The history (@Ac 18:27) confirms the existence of the custom here alluded to in the Epistle: "When Apollos was disposed to pass into Achaia [Corinth], the brethren [of Ephesus] wrote, exhorting the disciples to receive him." This was about two years before the Epistle,and is probably one of the instances to which Paul refers, as many at Corinth boasted of their being followers of Apollos (@1Co 1:12).

      2. our epistle--of recommendation.
      in our hearts--not letters borne merely in the hands. Your conversion through my instrumentality, and your faith which is "known of all men" by widespread report (@1Co 1:4-7), and which is written by memory and affection on my inmost heart and is borne about wherever I go, is my letter of recommendation (@1Co 9:2).
      known and read--words akin in root, sound, and sense (so @2Co 1:13). "Ye are known to be my converts by general knowledge: then ye are known more particularly by your reflecting my doctrine in your Christian life." The handwriting is first "known," then the Epistle is "read" [GROTIUS] (@2Co 4:2 1Co 14:25). There is not so powerful a sermon in the world, as a consistent Christian life. The eye of the world takes in more than the ear. Christians' lives are the only religious books the world reads. IGNATIUS [Epistle to the Ephesians, 10] writes, "Give unbelievers the chance of believing through you. Consider yourselves employed by God; your lives the form of language in which He addresses them. Be mild when they are angry, humble when they are haughty; to their blasphemy oppose prayer without ceasing; to their inconsistency, a steadfast adherence to your faith."

      3. declared--The letter is written so legibly that it can be "read by all men" (@2Co 3:2). Translate, "Being manifestly shown to be an Epistle of Christ"; a letter coming manifestly from Christ, and "ministered by us," that is, carried about and presented by us as its (ministering) bearers to those (the world) for whom it is intended: Christ is the Writer and the Recommender, ye are the letter recommending us.
      written not with ink, but with the Spirit of the living God--Paul was the ministering pen or other instrument of writing, as well as the ministering bearer and presenter of the letter. "Not with ink" stands in contrast to the letters of commendation which "some" at Corinth (@2Co 3:1) used. "Ink" is also used here to include all outward materials for writing, such as the Sinaitic tables of stone were. These, however, were not written with ink, but "graven" by "the finger of God" (@Ex 31:18 32:16). Christ's Epistle (His believing members converted by Paul) is better still: it is written not merely with the finger, but with the "Spirit of the living God"; it is not the "ministration of death" as the law, but of the "living Spirit" that "giveth life" (@2Co 3:6-8).
      not in--not on tables (tablets) of stone, as the ten commandments were written (@2Co 3:7).
      in fleshy tables of the heart--ALL the best manuscripts read, "On [your] hearts [which are] tables of flesh." Once your hearts were spiritually what the tables of the law were physically, tables of stone, but God has "taken away the stony heart out of your flesh, given you a heart of flesh" (fleshy, not fleshly, that is, carnal; hence it is written, "out of your flesh" that is, your carnal nature), @Eze 11:19 36:26. Compare @2Co 3:2, "As ye are our Epistle written in our hearts," so Christ has in the first instance made you "His Epistle written with the Spirit in (on) your hearts." I bear on my heart, as a testimony to all men, that which Christ has by His Spirit written in your heart [ALFORD]. (Compare @Pr 3:3 7:3 Jer 31:31-34). This passage is quoted by PALEY [Horæ Paulinæ] as illustrating one peculiarity of Paul's style, namely, his going off at a word into a parenthetic reflection: here it is on the word "Epistle." So "savor," @2Co 2:14-17.

      4. And--Greek, "But." "Such confidence, however (namely, of our 'sufficiency,' @2Co 3:5,6 2Co 2:16--to which he reverts after the parenthesis--as ministers of the New Testament, 'not hinting,' @2Co 4:1), we have through Christ (not through ourselves, compare @2Co 3:18) toward God" (that is, in our relation to God and His work, the ministry committed by Him to us, for which we must render an account to Him). Confidence toward God is solid and real, as looking to Him for the strength needed now, and also for the reward of grace to be given hereafter. Compare @Ac 24:15, "hope toward God." Human confidence is unreal in that it looks to man for its help and its reward.

      5. The Greek is, "Not that we are (even yet after so long experience as ministers) sufficient to think anything OF ourselves as (coming) FROM ourselves; but our sufficiency is (derived) FROM God." "From" more definitely refers to the source out of which a thing comes; "of" is more general.
      to think--Greek, to "reason out" or "devise"; to attain to sound preaching by our reasonings [THEODORET]. The "we" refers here to ministers (@2Pe 1:21).
      anything--even the least. We cannot expect too little from man, or too much from God.

      6. able--rather, as the Greek is the same, corresponding to @2Co 3:5, translate, "sufficient as ministers" (@Eph 3:7 Col 1:23).
      the new testament--"the new covenant" as contrasted with the Old Testament or covenant (@1Co 11:25 Ga 4:24). He reverts here again to the contrast between the law on "tables of stone," and that "written by the Spirit on fleshly tables of the heart" (@2Co 3:3).
      not of the letter--joined with "ministers"; ministers not of the mere literal precept, in which the old law, as then understood, consisted; "but of the Spirit," that is, the spiritual holiness which lay under the old law, and which the new covenant brings to light (@Mt 5:17-48) with new motives added, and a new power of obedience imparted, namely, the Holy Spirit (@Ro 7:6). Even in writing the letter of the New Testament, Paul and the other sacred writers were ministers not of the letter, but of the spirit. No piety of spirit could exempt a man from the yoke of the letter of each legal ordinance under the Old Testament; for God had appointed this as the way in which He chose a devout Jew to express his state of mind towards God. Christianity, on the other hand, makes the spirit of our outward observances everything, and the letter a secondary consideration (@Joh 4:24). Still the moral law of the ten commandments, being written by the finger of God, is as obligatory now as ever; but put more on the Gospel spirit of "love," than on the letter of a servile obedience, and in a deeper and fuller spirituality (@Mt 5:17-48 Ro 13:9). No literal precepts could fully comprehend the wide range of holiness which LOVE, the work of the Holy Spirit, under the Gospel, suggests to the believer's heart instinctively from the word understood in its deep spirituality.
      letter killeth--by bringing home the knowledge of guilt and its punishment, death; @2Co 3:7, "ministration of death" (@Ro 7:9).
      spirit giveth life--The spirit of the Gospel when brought home to the heart by the Holy Spirit, gives new spiritual life to a man (@Ro 6:4,11). This "spirit of life" is for us in Christ Jesus (@Ro 8:2,10), who dwells in the believer as a "quickening" or "life-giving Spirit" (@1Co 15:45). Note, the spiritualism of rationalists is very different. It would admit no "stereotyped revelation," except so much as man's own inner instrument of revelation, the conscience and reason, can approve of: thus making the conscience judge of the written word, whereas the apostles make the written word the judge of the conscience (@Ac 17:11 1Pe 4:1). True spirituality rests on the whole written word, applied to the soul by the Holy Spirit as the only infallible interpreter of its far-reaching spirituality. The letter is nothing without the spirit, in a subject essentially spiritual. The spirit is nothing without the letter, in a record substantially historical.

      7. the ministration of death--the legal dispensation, summed up in the Decalogue, which denounces death against man for transgression.
      written and engraven in stones--There is no "and" in the Greek. The literal translation is, "The ministration of death in letters," of which "engraven on stones" is an explanation. The preponderance of oldest manuscripts is for the English Version reading. But one (perhaps the oldest existing manuscript) has "in the letter," which refers to the preceding words (@2Co 3:6), "the letter killeth," and this seems the probable reading. Even if we read as English Version, "The ministration of death (written) in letters," alludes to the literal precepts of the law as only bringing us the knowledge of sin and "death," in contrast to "the Spirit" in the Gospel bringing us "life" (@2Co 3:6). The opposition between "the letters" and "the Spirit" (@2Co 3:8) confirms this. This explains why the phrase in Greek should be "in letters," instead of the ordinary one which English Version has substituted, "written and."
      was glorious--literally, "was made (invested) in glory," glory was the atmosphere with which it was encompassed.
      could not steadfastly behold--literally, "fix their eyes on." @Ex 34:30, "The skin of his face shone; and they were AFRAID to come nigh him." "Could not," therefore means here, "for FEAR." The "glory of Moses' countenance" on Sinai passed away when the occasion was over: a type of the transitory character of the dispensation which he represented (@2Co 3:11), as contrasted with the permanency of the Christian dispensation (@2Co 3:11).

      8. be rather glorious--literally, "be rather (that is, still more, invested) in glory." "Shall be," that is, shall be found to be in part now, but fully when the glory of Christ and His saints shall be revealed.

      9. ministration of condemnation--the law regarded in the "letter" which "killeth" (@2Co 3:6 Ro 7:9-11). The oldest existing manuscript seems to read as English Version. But most of the almost contemporary manuscripts, versions, and Fathers, read, "If to the ministration of condemnation there be glory."
      the ministration of righteousness--the Gospel, which especially reveals the righteousness of God (@Ro 1:17), and imputes righteousness to men through faith in Christ (@Ro 3:21-28 4:3,22-25), and imparts righteousness by the Spirit (@Ro 8:1-4).
      exceed--"abound."

      10. For even the ministration of condemnation, the law, @2Co 3:7 (which has been glorified at Sinai in Moses' person), has now (English Version translates less fitly, "was made . . . had") lost its glory in this respect by reason of the surpassing glory (of the Gospel): as the light of the stars and moon fades in the presence of the sun.

      11. was glorious--literally, "was with glory"; or "marked by glory."
      that which remaineth--abideth (@Re 14:6). Not "the ministry," but the Spirit, and His accompaniments, life and righteousness.
      is glorious--literally, "is in glory." The Greek "with" or "by" is appropriately applied to that of which the glory was transient. "In" to that of which the glory is permanent. The contrast of the Old and New Testaments proves that Paul's chief opponents at Corinth were Judaizers.

      12. such hope--of the future glory, which shall result from the ministration of the Gospel (@2Co 3:8,9).
      plainness of speech--openness; without reserve (@2Co 2:17 4:2).

      13. We use no disguise, "as Moses put a veil over his face, that the children of Israel might not look steadfastly upon the end of that which was to be done away" [ELLICOTT and others]. The view of @Ex 34:30-35, according to the Septuagint is adopted by Paul, that Moses in going in to speak to God removed the veil till he came out and had spoken to the people; and then when he had done speaking, he put on the veil that they might not look on the end, or the fading, of that transitory glory. The veil was the symbol of concealment, put on directly after Moses' speaking; so that God's revelations by him were interrupted by intervals of concealment [ALFORD]. But ALFORD'S view does not accord with @2Co 3:7; the Israelites "could not look steadfastly on the face of Moses for the glory of his countenance." Plainly Moses' veil was put on because of their not having been able to "look steadfastly at him." Paul here (@2Co 3:13) passes from the literal fact to the truth symbolized by it, the blindness of Jews and Judaizers to the ultimate end of the law: stating that Moses put on the veil that they might not look steadfastly at (Christ, @Ro 10:4) the end of that (law) which (like Moses' glory) is done away. Not that Moses had this purpose; but often God attributes to His prophets the purpose which He has Himself. Because the Jews would not see, God judicially gave them up so as not to see. The glory of Moses' face is antitypically Christ s glory shining behind the veil of legal ordinances. The veil which has been taken off to the believer is left on to the unbelieving Jew, so that he should not see (@Isa 6:10 Ac 28:26,27). He stops short at the letter of the law, not seeing the end of it. The evangelical glory of the law, like the shining of Moses' face, cannot be borne by a carnal people, and therefore remains veiled to them until the Spirit comes to take away the veil (@2Co 3:14-17) [CAMERON].

      14-18. Parenthetical: Of Christians in general. He resumes the subject of the ministry, @2Co 4:1.
      minds--Greek, "mental perceptions"; "understandings."
      blinded--rather, "hardened." The opposite to "looking steadfastly at the end" of the law (@2Co 3:13). The veil on Moses' face is further typical of the veil that is on their hearts.
      untaken away . . . which veil--rather, "the same veil . . . remaineth untaken away [literally, not unveiled], so that they do not see THAT it (not the veil as English Version, but 'THE OLD TESTAMENT,' or covenant of legal ordinances) is done away (@2Co 3:7,11,13) in Christ" or, as BENGEL, "Because it is done away in Christ," that is, it is not done away save in Christ: the veil therefore remains untaken away from them, because they will not come to Christ, who does away, with the law as a mere letter. If they once saw that the law is done away in Him, the veil would be no longer on their hearts in reading it publicly in their synagogues (so "reading" means, @Ac 15:21). I prefer the former.

      15. the veil is--rather, "a veil lieth upon their heart" (their understanding, affected by the corrupt will, @Joh 8:43 1Co 2:14). The Tallith was worn in the synagogue by every worshipper, and to this veil hanging over the breast there may be an indirect allusion here (see on 1Co 11:4): the apostle making it symbolize the spiritual veil on their heart.

      16. Moses took off the veil on entering into the presence of the Lord. So as to the Israelites whom Moses represents, "whensoever their heart (it) turns (not as English Version, 'shall turn') to the Lord, the veil is (by the very fact; not as English Version, 'shall be') taken away." @Ex 34:34 is the allusion; not @Ex 34:30,31, as ALFORD thinks. Whenever the Israelites turn to the Lord, who is the Spirit of the law, the veil is taken off their hearts in the presence of the Lord: as the literal veil was taken off by Moses in going before God: no longer resting on the dead letter, the veil, they by the Spirit commune with God and with the inner spirit of the Mosaic covenant (which answers to the glory of Moses' face unveiled in God's presence).

      17. the Lord--Christ (@2Co 3:14,16 2Co 4:5).
      is that Spirit--is THE Spirit, namely, that Spirit spoken of in @2Co 3:6, and here resumed after the parenthesis (@2Co 3:7-16): Christ is the Spirit and "end" of the Old Testament, ho giveth life to it, whereas "the letter killeth" (@1Co 15:45 Re 19:10, end).
      where the Spirit of the Lord is--in a man's "heart" (@2Co 3:15 Ro 8:9,10).
      there is liberty--(@Joh 8:36). "There," and there only. Such cease to be slaves to the letter, which they were while the veil was on their heart. They are free to serve God in the Spirit, and rejoice in Christ Jesus (@Php 3:3): they have no longer the spirit of bondage, but of free sonship (@Ro 8:15 Ga 4:7). "Liberty" is opposed to the letter (of the legal ordinances), and to the veil, the badge of slavery: also to the fear which the Israelites felt in beholding Moses' glory unveiled (@Ex 34:30 1Jo 4:18).

      18. But we all--Christians, as contrasted with the Jews who have a veil on their hearts, answering to Moses' veil on his face. He does not resume reference to ministers till @2Co 4:1.
      with open face--Translate, "with unveiled face" (the veil being removed at conversion): contrasted with "hid" (@2Co 4:3).
      as in a glass--in a mirror, namely, the Gospel which reflects the glory of God and Christ (@2Co 4:4 1Co 13:12 Jas 1:23,25).
      are changed into the same image--namely, the image of Christ's glory, spiritually now (@Ro 8:29 1Jo 3:3); an earnest of the bodily change hereafter (@Php 3:21). However many they be, believers all reflect the same image of Christ more or less: a proof of the truth of Christianity.
      from glory to glory--from one degree of glory to another. As Moses' face caught a reflection of God's glory from being in His presence, so believers are changed into His image by beholding Him.
      even as, &c.--Just such a transformation "as" was to be expected from "the Lord the Spirit" (not as English Version, "the Spirit of the Lord") [ALFORD] (@2Co 3:17): "who receives of the things of Christ, and shows them to us" (@Joh 16:14 Ro 8:10,11). (Compare as to hereafter, @Ps 17:15 Re 22:4).

      @2Co 4:1-18. HIS PREACHING IS OPEN AND SINCERE, THOUGH TO MANY THE GOSPEL IS HIDDEN.

      For he preaches Christ, not himself: the human vessel is frail that God may have the glory; yet, though frail, faith and the hope of future glory sustain him amidst the decay of the outward man.

      1. Therefore--Greek, "For this cause": Because we have the liberty-giving Spirit of the Lord, and with unveiled face behold His glory (@2Co 3:17,18).
      seeing we have this ministry--"The ministration of the Spirit" (@2Co 3:8,9): the ministry of such a spiritual, liberty-giving Gospel: resuming @2Co 3:6,8.
      received mercy--from God, in having had this ministry conferred on us (@2Co 3:5). The sense of "mercy" received from God, makes men active for God (@1Ti 1:11-13).
      we faint not--in boldness of speech and action, and patience in suffering (@2Co 4:2,8-16, &c.).

      2. renounced--literally, "bid farewell to."
      of dishonesty--rather, "of shame." "I am not ashamed of the Gospel of Christ" (@Ro 1:16). Shame would lead to hiding (@2Co 4:3); whereas "we use great plainness of speech" (@2Co 3:12); "by manifestation of the truth." Compare @2Co 3:3, "manifestly declared." He refers to the disingenuous artifices of "many" teachers at Corinth (@2Co 2:17 3:1 11:13-15).
      handling . . . deceitfully--so "corrupt" or adulterate "the word of God" (@2Co 2:17; compare @1Th 2:3,4).
      commending--recommending ourselves: recurring to @2Co 3:1.
      to--to the verdict of.
      every man's conscience--(@2Co 5:11). Not to men's carnal judgment, as those alluded to (@2Co 3:1).
      in the sight of God--(@2Co 2:17 Ga 1:10).

      3. But if--Yea, even if (as I grant is the case).
      hid--rather (in reference to @2Co 3:13-18), "veiled." "Hid" (Greek, @Col 3:3) is said of that withdrawn from view altogether. "Veiled," of a thing within reach of the eye, but covered over so as not to be seen. So it was in the case of Moses' face.
      to them--in the case only of them: for in itself the Gospel is quite plain.
      that are lost--rather, "that are perishing" (@1Co 1:18). So the same cloud that was "light" to the people of God, was "darkness" to the Egyptian foes of God (@Ex 14:20).

      4. In whom--Translate, "In whose case."
      god of this world--The worldly make him their God (@Php 3:19). He is, in fact, "the prince of the power of the air, the spirit that ruleth in the children of disobedience" (@Eph 2:2).
      minds--"understandings": "mental perceptions," as in @2Co 3:14.
      them which believe not--the same as "them that are lost" (or "are perishing"). Compare @2Th 2:10-12. SOUTH quaintly says, "when the malefactor's eyes are covered, he is not far from his execution" (@Es 7:8). Those perishing unbelievers are not merely veiled, but blinded (@2Co 3:14,15): Greek, not "blinded," but "hardened."
      light of the glorious gospel of Christ--Translate, "The illumination (enlightening: the propagation from those already enlightened, to others of the light) of the Gospel of the glory of Christ." "The glory of Christ" is not a mere quality (as "glorious" would express) of the Gospel; it is its very essence and subject matter.
      image of God--implying identity of nature and essence (@Joh 1:18 Col 1:15 Heb 1:3). He who desires to see "the glory of God," may see it "in the face of Jesus Christ" (@2Co 4:6 1Ti 6:14-16). Paul here recurs to @2Co 3:18. Christ is "the image of God," into which "same image" we, looking on it in the mirror of the Gospel, are changed by the Spirit; but this image is not visible to those blinded by Satan [ALFORD].

      5. For--Their blindness is not our fault, as if we had self-seeking aims in our preaching.
      preach . . . Christ . . . the Lord--rather, "Christ as Lord," and ourselves as your servants, &c. "Lord," or "Master," is the correlative term to "servants."

      6. For--proof that we are true servants of Jesus unto you.
      commanded the light--Greek, "By speaking the word, commanded light" (@Ge 1:3).
      hath shined--rather, as Greek, "is He who shined." (It is God) who commanded light, &c., that shined, &c., (@Job 37:15): Himself our Light and Sun, as well as the Creator of light (@Mal 4:2 Joh 8:12). The physical world answers to the spiritual.
      in our hearts--in themselves dark.
      to give the light--that is, to propagate to others the light, &c., which is in us (compare Note, see on 2Co 4:4).
      the glory of God--answering to "the glory of Christ" (see on 2Co 4:4).
      in the face of Jesus Christ--Some of the oldest manuscripts retain "Jesus." Others omit it. Christ is the manifestation of the glory of God, as His image (@Joh 14:9). The allusion is still to the brightness on Moses' "face." The only true and full manifestation of God's brightness and glory is "in the face of Jesus" (@Heb 1:3).

      7. "Lest any should say, How then is it that we continue to enjoy such unspeakable glory in a mortal body? Paul replies, this very fact is one of the most marvellous proofs of God's power, that an earthen vessel could bear such splendor and keep such a treasure" [CHRYSOSTOM, Homilies, 8.496, A]. The treasure or "the light of the knowledge of the glory of God." The fragile "earthen vessel" is the body, the "outward man" (@2Co 4:16; compare @2Co 4:10), liable to afflictions and death. So the light in Gideon's pitchers, the type (@Jud 7:16-20,22). The ancients often kept their treasures in jars or vessels of earthenware. "There are earthen vessels which yet may be clean; whereas a golden vessel may be filthy" [BENGEL].
      that the excellency of the power, &c.--that the power of the ministry (the Holy Spirit), in respect to its surpassing "excellency," exhibited in winning souls (@1Co 2:4) and in sustaining us ministers, might be ascribed solely to God, we being weak as earthen vessels. God often allows the vessel to be chipped and broken, that the excellency of the treasure contained, and of the power which that treasure has, may be all His (@2Co 4:10,11 Joh 3:30).
      may be of God . . . not of us--rather, as Greek, "may be God's (may be seen and be thankfully [@2Co 4:15] acknowledged to belong to God), and not (to come) from us." The power not merely comes from God, but belongs to Him continually, and is to be ascribed to him.

      8. Greek, "BEING hard pressed, yet not inextricably straitened; reduced to inextricable straits" (nominative to "we have," @2Co 4:7).
      on every side--Greek, "in every respect" (compare @2Co 4:10, "always"; @2Co 7:5). This verse expresses inward distresses; @2Co 4:9, outward distresses (@2Co 7:5). "Without were fightings; within were fears." The first clause in each member of the series of contrasted participles, implies the earthiness of the vessels; the second clause, the excellency of the power.
      perplexed, but not in despair--Greek, "not utterly perplexed." As perplexity refers to the future, so "troubled" or "hard pressed" refers to the present.

      9. not forsaken--by God and man. Jesus was forsaken by both; so much do His sufferings exceed those of His people (@Mt 27:46).
      cast down--or "struck down"; not only "persecuted," that is, chased as a deer or bird (@1Sa 26:20), but actually struck down as with a dart in the chase (@Heb 11:35-38). The Greek "always" in this verse means, "throughout the whole time"; in @2Co 4:11 the Greek is different, and means, "at every time," "in every case when the occasion occurs."

      10. bearing about in the body the dying of the Lord Jesus--that is, having my body exposed to being put to death in the cause of Jesus (the oldest manuscripts omit "the Lord"), and having in it the marks of such sufferings, I thus bear about wheresoever I go, an image of the suffering Saviour in my own person (@2Co 4:11 2Co 1:5; compare @1Co 15:31). Doubtless, Paul was exposed to more dangers than are recorded in Acts (compare @2Co 7:5 11:26). The Greek for "the dying" is literally, "the being made a corpse," such Paul regarded his body, yet a corpse which shares in the life-giving power of Christ's resurrection, as it has shared in His dying and death.
      that the life also of Jesus might be made manifest in our body--rather, "may be." The name "Jesus," by itself is often repeated here as Paul seems, amidst sufferings, peculiarly to have felt its sweetness. In @2Co 4:11 the same words occur with the variation, "in our mortal flesh. The fact of a dying, corpse-like body being sustained amidst such trials, manifests that "the (resurrection) life also," as well as the dying, "of Jesus," exerts its power in us. I thus bear about in my own person an image of the risen and living, as well as of the suffering, Saviour. The "our" is added here to "body," though not in the beginning of the verse. "For the body is ours not so much in death, as in life" [BENGEL].

      11. we which live--in the power of Christ's "life" manifested in us, in our whole man body as well as spirit (@Ro 8:10,11; see on 2Co 4:10; compare @2Co 5:15). Paul regards his preservation amidst so many exposures to "death," by which Stephen and James were cut off, as a standing miracle (@2Co 11:23).
      delivered unto--not by chance; by the ordering of Providence, who shows "the excellency of His power" (@2Co 4:7), in delivering unto DEATH His living saints, that He may manifest LIFE also in their dying flesh. "Flesh," the very element of decay (not merely their "body"), is by Him made to manifest life.

      12. The "death" of Christ manifested in the continual "perishing of our outward man" (@2Co 4:16), works peculiarly in us, and is the means of working spiritual "life" in you. The life whereof we witness in our bodily dying, extends beyond ourselves, and is brought by our very dying to you.

      13. Translate as Greek, "BUT having," &c. that is, not withstanding the trials just mentioned, we having, &c.
      the same spirit of faith, according as it, &c.--Compare @Ro 8:15, on the usage of "spirit of faith." The Holy Spirit acting on our spirit. Though "death worketh in us, and life in you" (@2Co 4:12), yet as we have the same spirit of faith as you, we therefore [believingly] look for the same immortal life as you [ESTIUS], and speak as we believe. ALFORD not so well translates, "The same . . . faith with that described in the Scriptures" (@Ps 116:10). The balance of the sentence requires the parallelism to be this, "According to that which is written, I believed, and therefore have I spoken; we also believe, and therefore speak," namely, without fear, amidst "afflictions" and "deaths" (@2Co 4:17).

      14. Knowing--by faith (@2Co 5:1).
      shall raise up us also--at the resurrection (@1Co 6:13,14).
      by Jesus--The oldest manuscripts have "with Jesus."
      present us--vividly picturing the scene before the eyes (@Jude 1:24).
      with you--(@2Co 1:14 1Th 2:19,20 3:13).

      15. For--Confirming his assertion "with you" (@2Co 4:14), and "life . . . worketh in you" (@2Co 4:12).
      all things--whether the afflictions and labors of us ministers (@2Co 4:8-11), or your prosperity (@2Co 4:12 1Co 3:21,22 4:8-13).
      for your sakes--(@2Ti 2:10).
      abundant grace, &c.--rather, "That grace (the grace which preserves us in trials and works life in you), being made the greater (multiplied), by means of the greater number (of its recipients), may cause the thanksgiving to abound to the glory of God." [CHRYSOSTOM] (@2Co 1:11 9:11,12). The Greek is susceptible also of this translation, "That grace, being made the greater (multiplied) on account of the thanksgiving of the greater number (for grace already received), may abound (abundantly redound) to," &c. Thus the Greek for "abound" has not to be taken in an active sense, but in its ordinary neuter sense, and so the other Greek words. Thanksgiving invites more abundant grace (@2Ch 20:19-22 Ps 18:3 50:23).

      16. we faint not--notwithstanding our sufferings. Resuming @2Co 4:1.
      outward man--the body, the flesh.
      perish--"is wearing away"; "is wasted away" by afflictions.
      inward man--our spiritual and true being, the "life" which even in our mortal bodies (@2Co 4:11) "manifests the life of Jesus."
      is renewed--"is being renewed," namely, with fresh "grace" (@2Co 4:15), and "faith" (@2Co 4:13), and hope (@2Co 4:17,18).

      17. which is but for a moment--"Our PRESENT light (burden of) affliction" (so the Greek; compare @Mt 11:30), [ALFORD]. Compare "now for a season . . . in heaviness" (@1Pe 1:6). The contrast, however, between this and the "ETERNAL weight of glory" requires, I think, the translation, "Which is but for the present passing moment." So WAHL. "The lightness of affliction" (he does not express "burden" after "light"; the Greek is "the light of affliction") contrasts beautifully with the "weight of the glory."
      worketh--rather, "worketh out."
      a far more exceeding and--rather, "in a surpassing and still more surpassing manner" [ALFORD]; "more and more exceedingly" [ELLICOTT, TRENCH, and others]. Greek, "in excess and to excess." The glory exceeds beyond all measure the affliction.

      18. look not at--as our aim.
      things . . . seen--"earthly things" (@Php 3:19). We mind not the things seen, whether affliction or refreshment come, so as to be seduced by the latter, or deterred by the former [CHRYSOSTOM].
      things . . . not seen--not "the invisible things" of @Ro 1:20, but the things which, though not seen now, shall be so hereafter.
      temporal--rather, "for a time"; in contrast to eternal. English Version uses "temporal" for temporary. The Greek is rightly translated in the similar passage, "the pleasures of sin for a season."

      @2Co 5:1-21. THE HOPE (@2Co 4:17,18) OF ETERNAL GLORY IN THE RESURRECTION BODY.

      Hence arises his ambition to be accepted at the Lord's coming judgment. Hence, too, his endeavor to deal openly with men, as with God, in preaching; thus giving the Corinthians whereof to boast concerning him against his adversaries. His constraining motive is the transforming love of Christ, by whom God has wrought reconciliation between Himself and men, and has committed to the apostle the ministry of reconciliation.

      1. For--Assigning the reason for the statement (@2Co 4:17), that affliction leads to exceeding glory.
      we know--assuredly (@2Co 4:14 Job 19:25).
      if--For all shall not die; many shall be "changed" without "dissolution" (@1Co 15:51-53). If this daily delivering unto death (@2Co 3:11) should end in actual death.
      earthly--not the same as earthy (@1Co 15:47). It stands in contrast to "in the heavens."
      house of this tabernacle--rather, "house of the tabernacle." "House" expresses more permanency than belongs to the body; therefore the qualification, "of the tabernacle" (implying that it is shifting, not stationary), is added (compare @Job 4:19 2Pe 1:13,14). It thus answers to the tabernacle in the wilderness. Its wooden frame and curtains wore out in course of time when Israel dwelt in Canaan, and a fixed temple was substituted for it. The temple and the tabernacle in all essentials were one; there was the same ark, the same cloud of glory. Such is the relation between the "earthly" body and the resurrection body. The Holy Spirit is enshrined in the believer's body as in a sanctuary (@1Co 3:16). As the ark went first in taking down the wilderness tabernacle, so the soul (which like the ark is sprinkled with blood of atonement, and is the sacred deposit in the inmost shrine, @2Ti 1:12) in the dissolution of the body; next the coverings were removed, answering to the flesh; lastly, the framework and boards, answering to the bones, which are last to give way (@Nu 4:1-49). Paul, as a tent-maker, uses an image taken from his trade (@Ac 18:3).
      dissolved--a mild word for death, in the case of believers.
      we have--in assured prospect of possession, as certain as if it were in our hands, laid up "in the heavens" for us. The tense is present (compare @Joh 3:36 6:47, "hath").
      a building of God--rather "from God." A solid building, not a temporary tabernacle or tent. "Our" body stands in contrast to "from God." For though our present body be also from God, yet it is not fresh and perfect from His hands, as our resurrection body shall be.
      not made with hands--contrasted with houses erected by man's hands (@1Co 15:44-49). So Christ's body is designated, as contrasted with the tabernacle reared by Moses (@Mr 14:58 Heb 9:11). This "house" can only be the resurrection body, in contrast to the "earthly house of the tabernacle," our present body. The intermediate state is not directly taken into account. A comma should separate "eternal," and "in the heavens."

      2. For in this--Greek, "For also in this"; "herein" (@2Co 8:10). ALFORD takes it, "in this" tabernacle. @2Co 5:4, which seems parallel, favors this. But the parallelism is sufficiently exact by making "in this we groan" refer generally to what was just said (@2Co 5:1), namely, that we cannot obtain our "house in the heavens" except our "earthly tabernacle" be first dissolved by death.
      we groan--(@Ro 8:23) under the body's weaknesses now and liability to death.
      earnestly desiring to be clothed upon--translate, "earnestly longing to have ourselves clothed upon," &c., namely, by being found alive at Christ's coming, and so to escape dissolution by death (@2Co 5:1,4), and to have our heavenly body put on over the earthly. The groans of the saints prove the existence of the longing desire for the heavenly glory, a desire which cannot be planted by God within us in vain, as doomed to disappointment.
      our house--different Greek from that in @2Co 5:1; translate, "our habitation," "our domicile"; it has a more distinct reference to the inhabitant than the general term "house" (@2Co 5:1) [BENGEL].
      from heaven--This domicile is "from heaven" in its origin, and is to be brought to us by the Lord at His coming again "from heaven" (@1Th 4:16). Therefore this "habitation" or "domicile" is not heaven itself.

      3. If so be, &c.--Our "desire" holds good, should the Lord's coming find us alive. Translate, "If so be that having ourselves clothed (with our natural body, compare @2Co 5:4) we shall not be found naked (stripped of our present body)."

      4. For--resuming @2Co 5:2.
      being burdened: not for that--rather, "in that we desire not to have ourselves unclothed (of our present body), but clothed upon (with our heavenly body).
      that mortality, &c.--rather, "that what is mortal (our mortal part) may be swallowed up of (absorbed and transformed into) life." Believers shrink from, not the consequences, but the mere act of dying; especially as believing in the possibility of their being found alive at the Lord's coming (@1Th 4:15), and so of having their mortal body absorbed into the immortal without death. Faith does not divest us of all natural feeling, but subordinates it to higher feeling. Scripture gives no sanction to the contempt for the body expressed by philosophers.

      5. wrought us--framed us by redemption, justification, and sanctification.
      for the selfsame thing--"unto" it; namely, unto what is mortal of us being swallowed up in life (@2Co 5:4).
      who also--The oldest manuscripts omit "also."
      earnest of the Spirit--(See on 2Co 1:22). It is the Spirit (as "the first-fruits") who creates in us the groaning desire for our coming deliverance and glory (@Ro 8:23).

      6. Translate as Greek, "Being therefore always confident and knowing," &c. He had intended to have made the verb to this nominative, "we are willing" (rather, "well content"), but digressing on the word "confident" (@2Co 5:6,7), he resumes the word in a different form, namely, as an assertion: "We are confident and well content." "Being confident . . . we are confident" may be the Hebraic idiom of emphasis; as @Ac 7:34, Greek, "Having seen, I have seen," that is, I have surely seen.
      always--under all trials. BENGEL makes the contrast between "always confident" and "confident" especially at the prospect of being "absent from the body." We are confident as well at all times, as also most of all in the hope of a blessed departure.
      whilst . . . at home . . . absent--Translate as Greek, "While we sojourn in our home in the body, we are away from our home in the Lord." The image from a "house" is retained (compare @Php 3:20 Heb 11:13-16 13:14).

      7. we walk--in our Christian course here on earth.
      not by sight--Greek, "not by appearance." Our life is governed by faith in our immortal hope; not by the outward specious appearance of present things [TITTMANN, Greek Synonyms of the New Testament]. Compare "apparently," the Septuagint, "by appearance," @Nu 12:8. WAHL supports English Version. @2Co 4:18 also confirms it (compare @Ro 8:24 1Co 13:12,13). God has appointed in this life faith for our great duty, and in the next, vision for our reward [SOUTH] (@1Pe 1:8).

      8. willing--literally, "well content." Translate also, "To go (literally, migrate) from our home in the body, and to come to our home with the Lord." We should prefer to be found alive at the Lord's coming, and to be clothed upon with our heavenly body (@2Co 5:2-4). But feeling, as we do, the sojourn in the body to be a separation from our true home "with the Lord," we prefer even dissolution by death, so that in the intermediate disembodied state we may go to be "with the Lord" (@Php 1:23). "To be with Christ" (the disembodied state) is distinguished from Christ's coming to take us to be with Him in soul and body (@1Th 4:14-17, "with the Lord"). Perhaps the disembodied spirits of believers have fulness of communion with Christ unseen; but not the mutual recognition of one another, until clothed with their visible bodies at the resurrection (compare @1Th 4:13:17), when they shall with joy recognize Christ's image in each other perfect.

      9. Wherefore--with such a sure "confidence" of being blessed, whether we die before, or be found alive at Christ's coming.
      we labour--literally, "make it our ambition"; the only lawful ambition.
      whether present or absent--whether we be found at His coming present in the body, or absent from it.
      accepted--Greek, "well-pleasing."

      10. appear--rather, "be made manifest," namely, in our true character. So "appear," Greek, "be manifested" (@Col 3:4; compare @1Co 4:5). We are at all times, even now, manifest to God; then we shall be so to the assembled intelligent universe and to ourselves: for the judgment shall be not only in order to assign the everlasting portion to each, but to vindicate God's righteousness, so that it shall be manifest to all His creatures, and even to the conscience of the sinner himself.
      receive--His reward of grace proportioned to "the things done," &c. (@2Co 9:6-9 2Jo 1:8). Though salvation be of grace purely, independent of works, the saved may have a greater or less reward, according as he lives to, and labors for, Christ more or less. Hence there is scope for the holy "ambition" (see on 2Co 5:9; @Heb 6:10). This verse guards against the Corinthians supposing that all share in the house "from heaven" (@2Co 5:1,2). There shall be a searching judgment which shall sever the bad from the good, accord